Mechanics I: The “Principles” and Equations of Motion
Mechanics I: The “Principle” and Equations of Motion
Inertial Frames
“What is an inertial system?”
“It is a c.s. in which the laws of mechanics are valid.”
— The Evolution of Physics [1]
Here, c.s. stands for co-ordinate system.
The inertial frame of reference, or inertial frame for short, provides the setting for mechanics and is a cornerstone of classical physics. An inertial frame is a frame of reference in which space can be described as homogeneous and isotropic, and time as homogeneous. Spatial homogeneity means that no position is privileged. Spatial isotropy means that no direction is privileged. Temporal homogeneity means that no instant is privileged. In other words, for an isolated system free from outside influences, changing the location, orientation, or starting time of the experiment as a whole should leave the laws of mechanics governing it unchanged.
Galileo’s inclined-plane thought experiment can help make this abstract idea more concrete. For now, let us set aside the causes of changes in motion and simply observe what a ball does. It speeds up as it rolls downhill and slows down as it rolls uphill. How, then, would it move on a level surface, where it neither climbs nor descends? Experiments show that the ball generally slows to a stop, but it tends to roll farther on a flatter, smoother surface. The distance it rolls therefore depends on the experimental conditions. Now place two inclined planes opposite each other and join them smoothly at the bottom. A ball released from rest on one side rolls down and then climbs the other side. As the experimental conditions improve, the height it reaches approaches its starting height. This suggests that if the impediments present in the actual experiment could be removed, the ball would rise to its original height on the other side. Now keep the release height fixed and gradually reduce the angle of the second incline. To reach the same height, the ball must travel farther and farther. Once the second surface is entirely level, the ball cannot regain its original height however far it travels, so it keeps moving. The thought experiment helps us understand that in an inertial frame, a free particle unaffected by other bodies remains at rest or moves in a straight line at constant velocity.
This is Newton’s first law, which also asserts that inertial frames exist.
Consider a second frame that moves at constant velocity relative to a known inertial frame, with no relative rotation of the coordinate axes. Observers in the two frames may record different velocities for the same object, but they agree on whether its velocity remains constant. The measured velocities differ only by the constant relative velocity of the frames. If the object moves in a straight line at constant speed in one frame, its velocity also remains constant in magnitude and direction in the other. The second frame therefore satisfies the condition for inertial motion and is itself an inertial frame. By contrast, in a non-inertial frame, even an object unaffected by other bodies need not remain at rest or move in a straight line at constant velocity. Viewed from a rotating platform, for example, a free object travelling in a straight line may appear to follow a curved path. Free motion alone gives us no way to single out a privileged inertial frame. Extending this equivalence to all the laws of mechanics gives Galileo’s principle of relativity. The laws of mechanics governing the same physical process have the same form in all inertial frames.
“The same” refers to the form of the laws. Observers in different frames may record different positions and velocities.
How can we determine whether a particular frame is inertial? A single direct measurement cannot fully establish the homogeneity and isotropy described above. We must observe the motion of objects, eliminate the effects of other bodies and the apparatus as far as possible, and check whether the observations agree with the law of inertia. Every experiment is limited in duration, spatial extent, and precision, so it cannot cover every possible case. Repeated experiments can test the applicability of inertial frames, within those limits. For the problems discussed in this part of the series, we can work in inertial frames throughout.
We take the existence of inertial frames as a starting point of the theory. This is also an essential part of Newton’s first law. Although we have yet to introduce the second law, treating the first merely as a special case of the second would overlook its role in the theory. Even if the second law yields uniform straight-line motion under a particular condition, its usual form already presupposes an inertial frame. Deriving that special case therefore cannot establish the existence of inertial frames.
Newton’s first law describes free motion and asserts that there are inertial frames in which bodies move this way, providing the basis for the dynamics that follows.
The “Principle” and Equations of Motion
“The fundamental laws can be put in the form of a principle of least action.”
— The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. II [2]
The principle of least action, referred to below as the principle, is widely used across physics. It offers a unified description by taking the entire trajectory over a time interval and using a quantity called the action to obtain the equations of motion. Laws of motion with different forms can thus be expressed within a single variational framework, illustrating the search for simplicity and unity in physics. In this article, we will approach mechanics through this principle.
“Least” is the traditional term. With the initial and final times and endpoint configurations fixed, any infinitesimal variation of the actual trajectory leaves the action unchanged to first order. The action is then said to be stationary.
The action is defined by
In other words, the action is the integral of the Lagrangian
What happens if we include acceleration in the Lagrangian? If the dependence on acceleration is nondegenerate, variation yields fourth-order equations of motion. To determine a trajectory, we must then specify the initial acceleration and its rate of change independently, in addition to the initial position and velocity [3]. The theory would therefore allow different trajectories with identical initial positions and velocities, depending on the values of those additional initial data. This conflicts with the observed behaviour of the systems considered here, so we use
Now fix the initial and final times and the generalised coordinates at those times. Infinitely many candidate trajectories satisfy these conditions. Even two trajectories that follow the same path through space correspond to different functions
To calculate the variation of the action, we impose
Integration by parts produces a total time derivative. Integrating it gives a boundary term that vanishes under the endpoint conditions.
The variations
This is the Euler–Lagrange equation. It provides a general method for obtaining the equations of motion from a Lagrangian. To apply it to a particular system, we still need to determine that system’s Lagrangian. Let us start with a free particle in an inertial frame. What quantities can its Lagrangian
Before determining its form, let us return to the variation of the action. The total time derivative produced by integration by parts can be integrated directly, leaving a term evaluated only at the endpoints. In deriving the Euler–Lagrange equation, this boundary term vanishes because the variations at the endpoints are zero. This suggests that we obtain the same equations of motion whenever we modify the action in a way that preserves its stationarity condition. One simple example is multiplying the entire Lagrangian by a nonzero constant
The initial and final times are fixed, and
The two Lagrangians give the same equations of motion and are equivalent as descriptions of the system’s dynamics.
Given that different Lagrangians can yield the same equations of motion, how should we choose one for a free particle? We have used the homogeneity of time and space to write it as
Expanding the first term on the left in powers of
The right-hand side is a total time derivative and is therefore at most first degree in velocity. Comparing the terms of first order in
Here
Dropping this term leaves the equations of motion unchanged. The free-particle Lagrangian therefore reduces to
In Cartesian coordinates, spatial isotropy requires this quadratic form to have the same value for all velocities of equal magnitude. Evaluate it at velocities of the same magnitude along the eigenvectors of
The coefficient
The particle’s mass
In the Cartesian coordinates
Why is momentum conserved? In terms of conjugate momentum, the Euler–Lagrange equation reads
If the Lagrangian does not explicitly depend on a coordinate
Having considered a free particle in an inertial frame, let us now see what happens when a particle is subject to an interaction. Take a fixed source as an example. Its effect on the particle may differ from one position to another. Moving the particle while leaving the source in place may therefore change the particle’s subsequent motion. For interactions that can be described by a function of position, we subtract a function
In Cartesian coordinates, the negative gradient of the potential energy with respect to position gives the force on the particle.
The minus sign indicates that the force points in the direction of steepest decrease in potential energy. A force that can be written as the negative gradient of a time-independent potential energy is called conservative. For a single particle of constant mass, substituting
In Cartesian coordinates,
Some velocity-dependent interactions can be included directly in the Lagrangian. Even a term linear in velocity can affect the equations of motion. If the term can be written as the total time derivative of a function, its integral changes only the boundary term in the action, so the term may be omitted.
Does our initial focus on interactions that can be represented by potential energy reveal a limit of the principle, given how often nonconservative forces occur in practice?
We can address this question by broadening our view from the objects we directly observe to the entire interacting system. Modern physics describes the fundamental interactions in nature in terms of gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak interactions. In a particular mechanics problem, we generally consider only a few variables directly relevant to the motion under study. Energy can be transferred to degrees of freedom outside the model through microscopic motion or electromagnetic radiation, for example. The observed motion then exhibits dissipation, which can be described using nonconservative forces. The appearance of these forces is therefore related to how we define the system’s boundaries. The principle can be used to construct a more complete description of the dynamics, while nonconservative forces can account for processes that the simpler model leaves implicit.
Finally, consider an isolated system of two particles in an inertial frame. Suppose their interaction potential
Since
The particles’ total momentum is therefore conserved, and the forces they exert on each other are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction. This is Newton’s third law.