Mechanics II: Symmetry and Conservation Laws
Mechanics II: Symmetry and Conservation Laws
In the previous article, we developed the basic framework of classical mechanics from the principle of least action. By varying the action, we obtained the Euler–Lagrange equations. We then used the properties of inertial frames to determine the Lagrangian of a free particle. This led us to momentum, potential energy, and force, and we derived Newton’s three laws in turn from the equations of motion. Along the way, we began to encounter conservation laws. The Lagrangian of a free particle has no explicit dependence on its position coordinates, so its momentum is conserved. Going from a single particle to a closed system, we found that the total momentum of the system is also conserved. These results bring us back to the question left open in the previous article. To see where conservation laws come from, we need to look beyond particular equations of motion and turn to symmetry. From that perspective, conservation laws that once seemed unrelated reveal a common origin.
Symmetry and Conservation Laws
However broadly or narrowly we define symmetry, it “is one idea by which man through the ages has tried to comprehend and create order, beauty, and perfection.”
— Symmetry [1]
In everyday language, “symmetry” often suggests balance, harmony, and beauty. It is widespread in nature and has influenced art and architecture as an aesthetic principle. In physics, we can describe symmetry in terms of transformations. For example, rotate a square by (90^\circ) about its centre or reflect it across one of its axes of symmetry, and the resulting figure coincides with the original. In other words, symmetry is the property of remaining unchanged under a transformation. The laws of nature can also exhibit this kind of invariance. In an inertial frame, for example, a free particle moves in a straight line at constant velocity. If we translate its entire trajectory in space or change the origin of time, the equations describing its motion retain the same form.
Mathematically, we define symmetry in terms of a transformation. Consider the field
We use a minus sign in the coordinate transformation so that the resulting expression for
has a plus sign. This discussion draws on Tong’s lecture notes [2].
The field value originally at
We can use this to calculate the change in the field.
To first order, this gives
To establish whether a transformation is a physical symmetry, we ask whether the physical laws remain unchanged under it. As discussed in the previous article, if a transformation adds only a total time derivative to the Lagrangian, it adds only an endpoint term to the action. With the endpoints held fixed, this term does not affect the variation of the action, so the equations of motion remain unchanged.
This is the infinitesimal change
then the action changes by at most a boundary term. The symmetries discussed below satisfy this condition.
Let the action over the spacetime region
The symmetry condition gives the first-order change in the action.
We can also vary the action directly.
When the field satisfies the Euler–Lagrange equations, the first term vanishes, leaving the second term.
Comparing the two expressions pointwise gives
We can then define the Noether current.
Once a coordinate system is chosen, we can write the equations in components.
This is Noether’s theorem. It states that every continuous global variational symmetry of the action has an associated Noether current whose divergence vanishes when the field satisfies its equations of motion. Noether’s theorem is a central result of theoretical physics. It tells us that every continuous symmetry has a corresponding conservation law [3].
Emmy Noether was a German mathematician. Several prominent scholars have described her as the greatest woman mathematician in history. In physics, the theorem she proved revealed the close connection between symmetries and conservation laws. It is one of the most important theorems in the development of modern physics. [4]
Noether’s theorem gives the continuity equation
Let
Here
If the net flux through the boundary
A simple example can help us understand conserved currents and charges. Imagine a house with three rooms,
Adding the three equations, each net crossing count appears as an outflow for one room and an inflow for another, so the terms cancel. If
In this analogy, the time component
The spatial components of the Noether current describe flow across a boundary. Here
Conservation Laws
Examples from Classical Mechanics
Consider a few examples from classical mechanics. We begin with spatial translations. In the chosen inertial frame, set
In classical mechanics, the coordinate
Since
We can use the same method to examine spatial rotations. If we choose the angle
For an infinitesimal rotation, write the rotation angle as a vector
Strictly speaking,
should be an upper index. In Euclidean space, we can use the metric to raise or lower it, giving .
Suppose this spatial rotation satisfies the symmetry condition. Substituting into the expression for the conserved current gives
Equivalently, we have
Since
Writing out the individual components gives
Putting the components together in vector form gives conservation of the total angular momentum.
We can examine time-translation symmetry in much the same way. As in the spatial case, we now consider the translation
The conserved quantity associated with time translations is energy. As an example in one dimension, suppose a particle moves in a potential
Substituting into the expression for energy gives
The particle’s kinetic and potential energies add up to a constant. This is the familiar law of conservation of mechanical energy.
Energy–Momentum Tensor
Canonical Energy–Momentum Tensor
In the previous section, we considered spatial and temporal translations separately in classical mechanics. We now apply the same idea to field theory, treating both as spacetime translations. Following the earlier convention, take
The first-order change in the Lagrangian density is a total divergence. Substituting the variation of the field and the corresponding boundary term into the earlier expression for the Noether current gives
Each choice of translation direction gives an associated Noether current. Collecting the conserved currents for translations in all directions gives the canonical energy–momentum tensor.
Since
This is the conservation equation for the canonical energy–momentum tensor. We now examine its components in four-dimensional Minkowski spacetime, with
The convention
is also possible. We use the former metric signature to raise and lower indices throughout the discussion below.
Consider the component
This expression gives the energy density of the field. Integrating over all of space
Next, consider
Its physical meaning can be seen from the time component of the conserved current.
A pure time translation selects
Next, consider
For a pure time translation, it gives the spatial components of the corresponding conserved current.
Expanding the time component of the conservation equation for the canonical energy–momentum tensor gives
Since
Finally, the purely spatial components of the energy–momentum tensor are
For a pure spatial translation, these components determine the spatial part of the corresponding conserved current.
Keeping the second index fixed, we can write the conservation equation as
Here
There is another way to interpret
The rate of change of the
| Component | Symmetry | Expression | Physical meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
|
|
Time translation |
|
Energy density |
|
|
Spatial translation |
|
Momentum density |
|
|
Time translation |
|
Energy flux density |
|
|
Spatial translation |
|
Momentum flux density |
Energy–Momentum Tensor
We can extend this idea to a manifold
We then call it a Killing vector field [6]. The Minkowski spacetime translations considered above provide an example. Given a tensor
Taking its covariant divergence gives
The Killing equation
Let us return to the case of flat spacetime. The canonical energy–momentum tensor obtained from spacetime translation symmetry obeys the conservation equation, and the covariant derivative of the constant vector field generating the translation vanishes. Thus
We therefore have a conserved current.
In the spacetime translations discussed above, the generating vector field
If this term is nonzero, the current is not conserved. If
We define the modified canonical tensor and call it the energy–momentum tensor.
First, let us see how the correction makes the tensor symmetric. Taking the antisymmetric part in (a,b) gives
Next, consider the conservation equation. Taking the covariant divergence of the new tensor gives
If the original tensor satisfies
It satisfies
In this way, for every continuous isometry of the metric generated by a Killing vector field, we can construct the corresponding conserved current from the same improved energy–momentum tensor.
This section draws on [6].
The Significance of Noether’s Theorem
“Pure mathematics is, in its way, the poetry of logical ideas.” Einstein goes on to describe the search for general operations that gather as many formal relationships as possible into a simple, logical whole. In pursuing this logical beauty, mathematicians find conceptual tools that let us probe the laws of nature more deeply.
— Einstein’s tribute to Noether [7]
Noether’s theorem changed how we understand physical laws. It did more than add another result to theoretical physics. Before it, conserved quantities were often treated as empirical facts. The theorem brought them together as consequences of continuous symmetries. Time-translation symmetry corresponds to conservation of energy, spatial translation symmetry to conservation of momentum, and spatial rotation symmetry to conservation of angular momentum. This is how symmetry enters the laws governing conserved quantities in the motion of matter.
Noether’s theorem also changed how physicists build theories. Given a theory, we can start from its symmetries and identify conserved quantities before solving the equations of motion. In developing a new theory, we can reason in the other direction. We first determine what symmetries the theory has, then use them to decide which terms can appear in the action. From explaining conservation laws in classical mechanics to constraining theories of fundamental interactions, symmetry has become a starting point for building physical theories. As a matter of method, Noether’s theorem changed the way physicists work by making the search for symmetries a central part of constructing theories.